The Big Debate
26 January 2012
The Big Debate on BBC Scotland 25/1/2012 was a big flop.
This was the first of several debates on the Scottish Independence referendum. It bodes ill for the following debates that this one was a squabble.
Will presenter Glenn Campbell learn from David Dimblebey who sits in the middle of the panel in Question Time so that he can see his audience? Glenn Campbell stood to one side of the stage, facing the panel, and therefore about half of the 200 members of the audience who wanted to participate in the debate were hardly involved as he spent half his time with them behind his shoulder. He told one member of the audience who asked a question about publishing legal advice that he would put it to Nicola Sturgeon, and completely forgot about it.
The best speaker was the writer and broadcaster Lesley Riddoch, outclassing the three politicians, Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, Scottish Labour leader Joanne Lamont and Lord Wallace the Advocate General of Scotland.

